"these are falsehoods and wonders." Ibn ʿAdī also listed them in "al-Kāmil" (p. 323/2), including this ḥadīth, but he did not mention Ḥudhayfah in its isnād and said after it: "No one narrates it except al-Faḍl ibn al-Mukhtār, and it is known by him, and most of it is not corroborated." Similarly, what al-Maqdisī reported (3/85/1-2) through the chain of ʿAbd Allāh ibn Ziyād from Zurʿah from Nāfiʿ from Ibn ʿUmar who said: Ṭūbā was mentioned in the presence of the Prophet (ṣallá Allāhu ʿalayhi wa-sallam), and the Prophet (ṣallá Allāhu ʿalayhi wa-sallam) said: O Abū Bakr, have you heard about Ṭūbā? He said: Allāh and His Messenger know best. He said: Ṭūbā is a tree in Paradise, only Allāh knows its length, a rider travels under one of its branches for seventy autumns, its leaves are garments, and birds resembling camels perch on it. Abū Bakr said: There are indeed soft birds there. He said: Softer than them are those who eat them, and you are among them, if Allāh wills." Ibn Kathīr remained silent about it in his "Tafsīr" (8/184-Manār), perhaps due to the obviousness of its defect, as ʿAbd Allāh ibn Ziyād, who is the Palestinian. Ibn Ḥibbān spoke about him and listed another ḥadīth for him and said: "This is not from the ḥadīths of the Messenger of Allāh (ṣallá Allāhu ʿalayhi wa-sallam)." Al-Ḥāfiẓ listed a third ḥadīth for him in "al-Lisān" from the path of Abū Nuʿaym with his isnād from him, and said: "Abū Nuʿaym said: The fault lies with ʿAbd Allāh ibn Ziyād." And for the entirety of the birds and that they resemble camels, there are two supporting narrations from the mursal reports of Yaḥyá al-Jazzār and al-Ḥasan al-Baṣrī, which Ibn Abī Shaybah reported (13/102-103) with two authentic isnāds from them.