← Previous Page 19 of 6550 Next →
pay attention to any of these individuals, nor to others like Imām al-Baghawī, who also deemed it good in "Sharḥ al-Sunnah" (14/237). There are many others if one were to trace them, nor to their principle of strengthening a ḥadīth by its multiple chains, as he did similarly with the ḥadīth before it, as you will see under number (11). The one alluded to began to weaken this ḥadīth from the two chains I mentioned there, saying about the first chain (518/23): "There is an unknown [narrator], Saʿd ibn al-Akhram." He ignored the following facts: that it was said he was a Companion, that Ibn Ḥibbān and al-ʿAjlī considered him trustworthy, that its narrators—al-Tirmidhī and al-Baghawī—deemed it good, and that al-Ḥākim and others previously mentioned authenticated it! He criticized the other chain by saying: "It contains Layth ibn Abī Sulaym, and he is weak." It is as if he discovered with this weakening something that was hidden from me! Even though I pointed out there his weakness by saying: "Its chain is ḥasan in supporting evidence." However, I indicated by this that his weakness is not severe, and therefore I deemed his ḥadīth good as supporting evidence. He did not respond to that at all, and this is not the method of scholars who..
يعبأ بهؤلاء جميعاً ولا بغيرهم كالإِمام البغوي؛ فإنه حسنه أيضاً في "شرح السنة" (١٤/٢٣٧) ، ومثلهم كثير لو تيسر تتبعهم، ولا بقاعدتهم في تقوية الحديث بمجموع طرقه؛ كما فعل مثله في الحديث الذي قبله كما ستراه برقم (١١) . فأخذ المومى إليه يضعف هذا الحديث من طريقيه اللذين ذكرتهما هناك، فقال في الطريق الأولى (٥١٨/٢٣) :"فيه جهالة سعد بن الأخرم". فتجاهل الحقائق التالية:أنه قيل بصحبته.وأنه وثقه ابن حبان والعجلي.وأنه حسنه مخرجوه: الترمذي، والبغوي.وتصحيح الحاكم وغيره ممَّن سبق ذكره! وأعل الطريق الأخرى بقوله:"فيه ليث بن أبي سليم، وهو ضعيف". وكأنه اكتشف بهذا التضعيف أمراً كان خافياً علي! مع أنني نبهت هناك على ضعفه بقولي:"وسنده حسن في الشواهد". ولكنني نبهت بهذا أن ضعفه ليس بشديد، ولذلك حسنت حديثه كشاهد، فلم يجب عن ذلك بشيء، وليست هذه طريقة العلماء الذين
← Previous Page 19 of 6550 Next →